{
  "date": "2026-09-10",
  "protocol": "crforge-starter-strategy-v1",
  "planSha256": "a517d98de7d1b3d97745bc16ea13a31f8aae050f0fde85550d5df62795d086d6",
  "engineRevision": "e16f21985e88d78fe76b1b86d18d31880539a9e4",
  "decisionSeconds": 2,
  "maxOutputTokens": 2048,
  "requestDeadlineSeconds": 60,
  "ratedGames": 20,
  "responses": 4288,
  "ratedCost": 83.35111276,
  "models": [
    {
      "id": "astra",
      "name": "Astra",
      "version": "GPT-6 Astra",
      "effort": "low",
      "model": "openai/gpt-6-astra",
      "canonicalVersion": "openai/gpt-6-astra-20260903",
      "wins": 8,
      "losses": 0,
      "draws": 0,
      "rating": 1907,
      "interval": [
        1582,
        2233
      ],
      "accepted": 231,
      "rejected": 13,
      "invalid": 0,
      "responses": 821,
      "meanLatency": 3.19,
      "cost": 35.92117,
      "meanCrownDelta": 0.875
    },
    {
      "id": "gemini",
      "name": "Gemini",
      "version": "Gemini 3 Flash Preview",
      "effort": "minimal",
      "model": "google/gemini-3-flash-preview",
      "canonicalVersion": "google/gemini-3-flash-preview-20251217",
      "wins": 5,
      "losses": 3,
      "draws": 0,
      "rating": 1602,
      "interval": [
        1277,
        1927
      ],
      "accepted": 240,
      "rejected": 80,
      "invalid": 127,
      "responses": 817,
      "meanLatency": 1.68,
      "cost": 2.55226,
      "meanCrownDelta": 0.375
    },
    {
      "id": "claude",
      "name": "Claude",
      "version": "Claude Opus 5",
      "effort": "low",
      "model": "anthropic/claude-opus-5",
      "canonicalVersion": "anthropic/claude-opus-5-20260723",
      "wins": 4,
      "losses": 4,
      "draws": 0,
      "rating": 1500,
      "interval": [
        1175,
        1825
      ],
      "accepted": 256,
      "rejected": 45,
      "invalid": 2,
      "responses": 843,
      "meanLatency": 6.0,
      "cost": 34.18565,
      "meanCrownDelta": 0.125
    },
    {
      "id": "terra",
      "name": "Terra",
      "version": "GPT-5.6 Terra",
      "effort": "low",
      "model": "openai/gpt-5.6-terra",
      "canonicalVersion": "openai/gpt-5.6-terra-20260709",
      "wins": 3,
      "losses": 5,
      "draws": 0,
      "rating": 1398,
      "interval": [
        1073,
        1723
      ],
      "accepted": 306,
      "rejected": 81,
      "invalid": 1,
      "responses": 908,
      "meanLatency": 4.53,
      "cost": 9.88838,
      "meanCrownDelta": -0.625
    },
    {
      "id": "luna",
      "name": "Luna",
      "version": "GPT-5.6 Luna",
      "effort": "none",
      "model": "openai/gpt-5.6-luna",
      "canonicalVersion": "openai/gpt-5.6-luna-20260709",
      "wins": 0,
      "losses": 8,
      "draws": 0,
      "rating": 1093,
      "interval": [
        767,
        1418
      ],
      "accepted": 280,
      "rejected": 335,
      "invalid": 1,
      "responses": 899,
      "meanLatency": 1.92,
      "cost": 0.80365,
      "meanCrownDelta": -0.75
    }
  ],
  "games": [
    {
      "id": "game-001",
      "blue": "gemini",
      "red": "luna",
      "winner": "gemini",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 1,
        "red": 0
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 204.6,
      "decisions": 103,
      "cost": 0.41383022,
      "handSeeds": [
        76507338244547,
        49201019020636
      ],
      "replaySha256": "1380ca931c11228f18eac1e410680a30e8d0f24deaca570f45bf982868b34bf5"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-002",
      "blue": "luna",
      "red": "gemini",
      "winner": "gemini",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 0,
        "red": 1
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 180.05,
      "decisions": 91,
      "cost": 0.36024814,
      "handSeeds": [
        76507338244547,
        49201019020636
      ],
      "replaySha256": "504fa9364ace864a0ea4aa4d8141ece1cc9b0f4d90ce0226fcfdf3ee6e4e65f0"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-003",
      "blue": "claude",
      "red": "astra",
      "winner": "astra",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 0,
        "red": 1
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 180.05,
      "decisions": 91,
      "cost": 7.4976375,
      "handSeeds": [
        68351729359234,
        178840747227533
      ],
      "replaySha256": "b723cf73548b29fdf61f03cf7b8caa76804216b66ffa60b04963af304994fc00"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-004",
      "blue": "astra",
      "red": "claude",
      "winner": "astra",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 1,
        "red": 0
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 212.55,
      "decisions": 107,
      "cost": 9.0059815,
      "handSeeds": [
        68351729359234,
        178840747227533
      ],
      "replaySha256": "5e172a2cf62f9194bc8705fc9ffc4c738b2da8a8884c1cfe895bc98961976d42"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-005",
      "blue": "luna",
      "red": "terra",
      "winner": "terra",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 0,
        "red": 0
      },
      "tiebreak": true,
      "seconds": 300.05,
      "decisions": 151,
      "cost": 1.81062419,
      "handSeeds": [
        89325701823768,
        77854646796451
      ],
      "replaySha256": "b51eb4ebd3461e6fe92d61f29aec5d17b114b61d7510927c5b2ad9a0c23e8c1d"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-006",
      "blue": "terra",
      "red": "luna",
      "winner": "terra",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 1,
        "red": 1
      },
      "tiebreak": true,
      "seconds": 300.05,
      "decisions": 151,
      "cost": 1.89430484,
      "handSeeds": [
        89325701823768,
        77854646796451
      ],
      "replaySha256": "1e5fad3367b232d5ac1c23533b0ad4a725b596b654a933ce3edfdfd8afa4c6af"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-007",
      "blue": "terra",
      "red": "gemini",
      "winner": "gemini",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 0,
        "red": 1
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 180.05,
      "decisions": 91,
      "cost": 1.2823679,
      "handSeeds": [
        157552392305502,
        99869005680678
      ],
      "replaySha256": "089c677ddcb1048b9b9947f02155f258784bd74e4086cbb54a344aa9f708b37a"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-008",
      "blue": "gemini",
      "red": "terra",
      "winner": "gemini",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 1,
        "red": 0
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 180.05,
      "decisions": 91,
      "cost": 1.2180969,
      "handSeeds": [
        157552392305502,
        99869005680678
      ],
      "replaySha256": "eac62b5ba1b02c9ebc63a30c455aa6806219dbec1989181111930cd7cd31935e"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-009",
      "blue": "astra",
      "red": "luna",
      "winner": "astra",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 1,
        "red": 0
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 180.05,
      "decisions": 91,
      "cost": 4.12381939,
      "handSeeds": [
        194981260178976,
        269805147138379
      ],
      "replaySha256": "42848901e0a62d9035e03611cd5c8717aea4ba27eaaa00685ce54be8172ca0eb"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-010",
      "blue": "luna",
      "red": "astra",
      "winner": "astra",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 0,
        "red": 1
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 180.05,
      "decisions": 91,
      "cost": 4.04530299,
      "handSeeds": [
        194981260178976,
        269805147138379
      ],
      "replaySha256": "78cebca107f9934b8d78f4bcf96cb99302b833205951e8897a98ddbe82095c57"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-011",
      "blue": "claude",
      "red": "luna",
      "winner": "claude",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 1,
        "red": 0
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 258.8,
      "decisions": 130,
      "cost": 5.4445509,
      "handSeeds": [
        265573660869451,
        61545861134692
      ],
      "replaySha256": "2d397d6e5342fc137f787e3fd4483caa356de07d307877cc6f2f5564a0a1b38b"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-012",
      "blue": "luna",
      "red": "claude",
      "winner": "claude",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 0,
        "red": 1
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 180.05,
      "decisions": 91,
      "cost": 3.72805699,
      "handSeeds": [
        265573660869451,
        61545861134692
      ],
      "replaySha256": "5c05b0fe7fe4a96a5cc84d780829dfb12af71cd91c3af25d0ff2a55b5d9d595d"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-013",
      "blue": "gemini",
      "red": "astra",
      "winner": "astra",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 0,
        "red": 0
      },
      "tiebreak": true,
      "seconds": 300.05,
      "decisions": 151,
      "cost": 7.251095,
      "handSeeds": [
        125916653440802,
        185175746790861
      ],
      "replaySha256": "77cd9e80f59e5e1971449f946ce6366ab2d658b7ac5729e4aa197f34f6bffe91"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-014",
      "blue": "astra",
      "red": "gemini",
      "winner": "astra",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 1,
        "red": 0
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 215.3,
      "decisions": 108,
      "cost": 5.118636,
      "handSeeds": [
        125916653440802,
        185175746790861
      ],
      "replaySha256": "3c44dbe874d53687d9c833e1d0e76b0037ff0b585e71c084acd2107e9dce6bd0"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-015",
      "blue": "terra",
      "red": "astra",
      "winner": "astra",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 0,
        "red": 1
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 180.05,
      "decisions": 91,
      "cost": 4.833203,
      "handSeeds": [
        183118068681807,
        36165954607040
      ],
      "replaySha256": "8813494bfe551f73cfb9b1c4ad45791f211ab177f3002b0cc70fadc8677cc3ff"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-016",
      "blue": "astra",
      "red": "terra",
      "winner": "astra",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 1,
        "red": 0
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 180.05,
      "decisions": 91,
      "cost": 4.9075474,
      "handSeeds": [
        183118068681807,
        36165954607040
      ],
      "replaySha256": "e5f5f38a73aebc5ffbfa67b3f27df30295f12464530ef7ff3571ed37114b37b4"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-017",
      "blue": "claude",
      "red": "terra",
      "winner": "claude",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 1,
        "red": 0
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 180.05,
      "decisions": 91,
      "cost": 4.4383264,
      "handSeeds": [
        181183574952269,
        96879431836353
      ],
      "replaySha256": "1f135f86053457859c447ae58007faea27f5fd3814a92dc38cd88e445938aa4b"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-018",
      "blue": "terra",
      "red": "claude",
      "winner": "terra",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 0,
        "red": 0
      },
      "tiebreak": true,
      "seconds": 300.05,
      "decisions": 151,
      "cost": 8.059758,
      "handSeeds": [
        181183574952269,
        96879431836353
      ],
      "replaySha256": "584e8966e2ef86974ec077e9fa82633c1a1f7ded2537e93837d9e1f40f1866df"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-019",
      "blue": "gemini",
      "red": "claude",
      "winner": "gemini",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 1,
        "red": 0
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 180.05,
      "decisions": 91,
      "cost": 3.9238145,
      "handSeeds": [
        187654802882162,
        268171964874891
      ],
      "replaySha256": "8b5013b5a21edb6aa2c473e6df47fd802b6066f6759bf4f7bb64653174752631"
    },
    {
      "id": "game-020",
      "blue": "claude",
      "red": "gemini",
      "winner": "claude",
      "crowns": {
        "blue": 1,
        "red": 0
      },
      "tiebreak": false,
      "seconds": 180.05,
      "decisions": 91,
      "cost": 3.993911,
      "handSeeds": [
        187654802882162,
        268171964874891
      ],
      "replaySha256": "7c866f1aa09d88ed1a3ea7755235a29234c8e9ad6c1b34cbb0830324550b682f"
    }
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "Eight games per model; paired games are correlated. Rating \u00b1 2 RD is Glicko uncertainty, not a calibrated confidence interval.",
    "One fixed level-11 starter deck in a declared CRForge ruleset; structured observations, not screenshots.",
    "Reasoning settings differ across families; this is not an equal-compute comparison.",
    "Three Gemini interruptions were excluded and preserved. Game 019 restarted with original seeds; final two games used a nominal 12-second wall cooldown between decisions, with no simulated time passing.",
    "Application retries were zero; the underlying SDK retained two transport retries."
  ]
}